Resources
Why Minnesota Home Insurance Rates Are Rising
If your homeowners renewal came in higher than last year, you are not imagining it and you are not alone. Several pressures have been pushing Minnesota home insurance costs up at once, and no single one of them explains the whole picture.
Written and reviewed by Dassel State Insurance Agency · Last updated October 30, 2026
Severe weather is the pressure everyone feels first
The Minnesota Department of Commerce points to extreme weather as one of the primary drivers behind recent homeowner and auto premium increases, alongside reinsurance and the cost of labor and supplies. Minnesota is a hail and wind state, and those storms have been expensive.
Commerce reports that 2022 was Minnesota’s costliest storm year on record, with roughly $6.3 billion in property damage from events such as windstorms and hailstorms. A single hailstorm on August 11, 2023 caused more than $1 billion in property damage on its own. When losses of that size arrive repeatedly, they work their way into what insurers charge the following year.
It is worth being precise about what this does and does not mean. Statewide weather losses influence the rates a company files, but they are not the only input, and they do not move every household the same way.
What it costs to put a house back together
A homeowners policy is a promise to repair or rebuild, so it tracks construction costs rather than real estate prices. Commerce names higher labor and supply costs as a primary driver, tied to labor shortages, longer waits for materials, inflation and broader economic conditions.
This is the part that surprises people most. Your home can be worth the same as last year and still cost meaningfully more to rebuild, because rebuilding is bought in lumber, shingles, drywall and tradespeople’s hours. If that distinction is new to you, our note on replacement cost and market value covers it properly.
Insurers buy insurance too
Insurance companies purchase their own coverage, called reinsurance, to protect themselves against catastrophic years. Commerce notes that reinsurance costs have risen significantly, driven by the same billion-dollar weather events, and that many reinsurers have been adjusting what they will cover.
Reinsurance is invisible to customers, but it is a real cost of doing business, and when it rises it tends to show up in retail premiums across a market rather than for one company alone.
Then there is your particular house
Statewide pressures set the backdrop. What lands on your renewal also reflects the property itself and the history attached to it.
The home and its condition
Age, size, construction type, and the condition and age of the roof, wiring, plumbing and heating can all matter. Roofs draw particular attention in a hail state, and some carriers treat older roofs differently from newer ones.
Claim history
Prior claims, on the home and sometimes in the area, may be considered. How much weight that carries differs by company.
Insurers do not all rate the same way
This is the point worth holding onto. Each company files its own rates and uses its own rating factors, subject to review by the Department of Commerce. Two companies can look at the same house and the same history and reach genuinely different conclusions. That is precisely why comparing is worth the effort, and why no one can tell you what your premium will be without actually quoting it.
Coverage itself may be changing, not just price
Premium is only half the story. Commerce has reported that homeowner insurance complaints more than doubled between 2020 and 2023, from 569 to 1,185, with many concerning denied claims or large out-of-pocket costs after wind and hail damage. It has specifically warned that some carriers have introduced exclusions that narrow coverage, or separate and significantly higher deductibles for wind and hail, and that homeowners often do not notice until they file a claim.
Two things are worth knowing. Changes to premium, coverage amounts and exclusions commonly take effect at renewal, so a renewal packet is worth actually reading. And Minnesota law does not address policy exclusions for cosmetic damage from hail or wind, so whether your policy covers cosmetic damage is a question about your policy rather than about state law.
Separately, standard homeowners policies do not cover flood damage. Flood coverage is bought separately, and flooding is not confined to mapped floodplains.
What you can do
None of this is within your control, but a few things are worth your time before the next renewal.
- Read the renewal packet rather than filing it. Changes to deductibles, limits and exclusions usually arrive here.
- Find your wind and hail deductible specifically, and check whether it is a flat dollar amount or a percentage of the dwelling limit.
- Check whether roof losses are settled on a replacement cost or actual cash value basis.
- Confirm the dwelling limit still reflects what rebuilding would cost today, not what the house would sell for.
- Tell us about improvements. A new roof, updated wiring or a new furnace may be relevant to how a carrier views the risk.
- Ask what mitigation or protective device credits a carrier offers, and whether anything you have already done may qualify.
- Ask about flood coverage if water has ever been a concern, mapped floodplain or not.
- Compare before assuming a number is the market. Because insurers rate differently, it is worth checking.
Rates, coverage, eligibility and available options vary by person, property, vehicle, carrier and policy, and insurers do not all weigh the same factors. This page is general information, not individualized insurance, legal or financial advice. What a policy covers depends on its terms, conditions, limits and exclusions.
Sources and further reading
These are the public sources behind the factual points above. They are not affiliated with the agency, and they are worth reading directly.
- Minnesota Department of Commerce, Trend: Homeowner and Auto Insurance Rates Rising — the department’s summary of extreme weather, reinsurance, and labor and supply costs as primary drivers.
- Minnesota Department of Commerce, Complaints to MN Department of Commerce about homeowner insurance doubled since 2020 — complaint volumes and warnings about narrowed coverage and wind and hail deductibles.
- Minnesota Department of Commerce, Consumer alert: check insurance coverage for wind, hail limits — cosmetic damage exclusions, renewal changes and flood coverage.
- Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, Minnesota Climate Journal — a chronology of significant Minnesota weather events.
- Federal Emergency Management Agency, FloodSmart — flood insurance basics.
Talk it through with a local agent
If your renewal moved and you would like someone to read the declarations page with you, that is a short conversation and we are happy to have it.